Islam suggests that if we sin, we should not announce those wrong doings in public –
Abu Hurairah (May Allah be pleased with him) reported: Messenger of Allah (PBUH) said,
“Every one of my followers will be forgiven except those who expose (openly) their wrongdoings. An example of this is that of a man who commits a sin at night which Allah has covered for him, and in the morning, he would say (to people): “I committed such and such sin last night,’ while Allah had kept it a secret. During the night Allah has covered it up but in the morning he tears up the cover provided by Allah Himself.”
[Al-Bukhari and Muslim].
In this case, the night can be understood literally, as many grave sins are committed during the night, or figuratively, as many of our sins are committed behind some sort of cover. Be it solitude, the walls of our room or any other kind of cover, we sin in private because of our inherit understanding that what we’re doing is wrong. I believe it is imperative for us to keep our sins hidden because they should be inevitably associated with shame and repentance. To sin is in our human, flawed nature.. but we can at least acknowledge that what we’re doing is wrong. If we boast with our action and announce it to others, it is implied that we’re not acknowledging how wrong it really is and that, in fact, it is not that big of a deal at all. It belittles the sin and makes it seem trivial, and that in itself is rather severe in my opinion – because each sin is relevant and should be treated as such.
But much more than any of that, what concerns me most about such an attitude toward our sin is this notion of endorsement that the exposure of sins entails. Announcing your sins that have been hidden from others makes them seem normal, okay, and acceptable. If you’re in a group of friends and everyone in that group talks about how they frequently miss prayer and that it’s really not important to them, you’re going to be influenced to think that this kind of behavior is normal, and perhaps even acceptable. Of course, that doesn’t always imply that you will let it affect your actions but in general, such an environment in which sins are exposed so nonchalantly has a negative impact in that it champions sinful conduct.
Lately, a lot of the Muslim youth around me have been engaging in premarital relationships. While I want to leave my commentary on those kind of relationships for another post.. I want to make a point that I can count the my single friends on the fingers of my hand. I’ve come to see that this openness in talking about relationships has made some of those single friends fell utterly left out and lonely. Some even said that they’re feeling like they’re missing out on life and that they’re seriously considering pursuing a relationship with someone just to get rid of this feeling. It is so unfortunate that people who are living this very noble and commendable lifestyle start to doubt themselves because of how vices have come to be so socially acceptable.
Another example is weed. Lately, a lot of the Muslim youth have been smoking it.. and if they haven’t openly admitted to smoking it, they’ve at least endorsed its usage by saying, “There is no where in the Qur’an that specifically prohibits the smoking of Marijuana!” Well, there isn’t a specific passage for LSD, ecstasy and meth either.. are you going to endorse that, too? Oh wait.. some actually have. In any case, I was talking to my friend about this and she was asking why it is that weed has become so normal now. I suggested that it is because everyone started speaking about it so openly, it’s not a stigma anymore because “even [insert random, supposed pious person who went to madrassah, took Fiqh classes or happens to be from a religious family here] smokes it”!
Other examples include some of the “good kids” in the Muslim community who have never really done anything severely wrong in their lives, wanting to do all sorts of things – smoke, drink, party, date, sneak out, take of the hijab, get tattoos & piercings – because they hear that their Muslim friends from similar backgrounds have done it. Those friends have labeled it their “rebellious stage” in an attempt to justify it.. so the good kids are like, “I want to rebel because it seems like I’m missing out on life because I’m not rebelling.” It saddens me because instead of their peers and friends bringing out the best in them, they’re bringing out the worst in them by tempting them to do wrong just for the heck of it. I realize that everyone is individually responsible for his/her actions, however, I believe it is not healthy to be in or create an environment in which sins are not only belittled but promoted.
All of thise just further proves my point that every ruling in Islam came to either bring benefit or prevent harm. This ruling of not exposing ones hidden sins prevents harm in that it prevents the endorsement thereof. Our sins and our past belong to us and are between us and Allah swt only. They shouldn’t be shared with others without a good reason (e.g. wanting advice). I’m more likely to do something bad if it is socially acceptable in my group of peers etc. Unfortunately, we often feel like we have to account for our actions to people, instead of accounting for them to Allah swt. You never know, some of your friends may look up to you and view you as a role model without you knowing. So, if you do something bad, they might think: “Oh if even ____ does it, it can’t be that bad.” It’s unfortunate enough that we carry this load of sins with us.. but do you really want to add to the load by influencing others to commit those sins as well?